How to Poach an Egg (Tiny Pot Method)

Learning how to poach an egg is one of the most satisfying things you can do in the kitchen. In this post I'll be sharing the method that helped me hone my skills. I call it the "tiny pot" method because it requires using a very tiny pot.

Why make a poached egg

Is there anything more beautiful than a perfectly poached egg? A poached egg is the sweet, sensitive softboi cousin of the hard boiled egg.

While a hard boiled egg cooks safely inside its armor shell, a poached egg lets its walls down and cooks in a hot water bath. The egg whites gently wrap around the yolk as they slowly solidify, protecting that liquid golden center.

A poached egg is a staple with my homemade english muffins and eggs benedict, of course, but they're also great in spinach salads, on juicy turkey burgers, on top of pasta, or even, as pictured below, perched on top of a crispy scallion potato pancake with some homemade guacamole.

Poached eggs are simple, but require patience and a willingness to fail at least a little bit some of the time (no one in the world has a 100% track record with poached eggs).

There are tons of techniques (swirl the water!) and tips (add salt!) and tricks (no, add vinegar!) and tools and gadgets out there to help you master it, but there's one method I've found that works really well for me, which is what I'm sharing with you today.

If you've ever tried and failed to poach an egg you may have experienced one of the following:

• Egg whites spreading out throughout the entire pot turning the water into a cloudy mess.
• Egg white not fully enclosing the yolk.
• Yolk bursting open when the egg hits the bottom of the pan.
• Yolk too soft.
• Yolk too hard.
• Whites too hard.
• Whites too soft.

The solution to all of these problems is what I call the Tiny Pot Method. It's exactly what it sounds like: use a tiny pot, like this 2 cup butter warming pot, to poach a single egg at a time.

This method won't work so well if you're trying to make eggs benedict for a crowd, but in terms of familiarizing yourself with the process, it's is a great place to start.

How to Poach an Egg ("Tiny Pot Method")

1. Crack an egg into a mesh strainer to remove watery whites. Strain the egg, then dump the contents of the cup out and transfer the egg into the cup.
2. Bring a small pot of water with a splash of white vinegar to a low simmer (180-190F). Swirl the water to create a small whirlpool in the center of the pot, then dip the lip of the bowl in the water and let the egg slip out. The egg will tumble around the center of the pot because of the whirlpool, which helps ensure that the yolk is centered in the white and the small size of the pot keeps the whites from spreading out.
3. Cook the egg for 4-5 minutes, checking the water temp periodically. Adjust burner as needed to maintain 180-190F. Keep the water at a very gentle simmer — it might not even look like anything is happening in the pot. You might see a few tiny bubbles, you might not. You definitely do not want a boil.
4. Use a slotted spoon to gently remove the egg from the pot when it's done cooking. Rest the spoon with the egg in it on a paper towel to absorb some of the water, and then gently dab the surface of the egg to absorb any water pooling on top. Transfer the cooked egg to a plate.

Practical Tips & Recipe Notes

• I use a small All-Clad stainless steel butter warmer as my tiny pot but any small .5 quart (1-2 cup) pot will do!
• The splash of vinegar is optional but helps the egg white coagulate. Too much will make your egg taste vinegary, so you want just a small splash.
• Cracking the egg into a small wire mesh strainer removes the watery portion of the egg white so that all you're working with the firmer part of the white. Older eggs will be less watery. If you don't do this step, you're more likely to end up with cloudy water as the watery egg white spreads out.
• Do not leave the egg sitting in the strainer for longer than 30 seconds. The wire will cut into it and you'll have a hard time getting the egg out of the strainer. You want it in just long enough to strain out the watery part of the egg white. Then you'll empty the small bowl and tip the egg into it.
• Check the temperature of the water periodically throughout the cook time — you want it to be between 180°F and 190°F. I find it's easiest to add the egg at 190°F and then reduce the temp as the egg cooks. If you add the egg at 180°F, the egg will reduce the temp of the water and it can be hard to get it back up fast enough.

Making Poached Eggs Ahead of Time

Poached eggs can be made up to 5 days in advance. Store them in a shallow, airtight container filled with water in the fridge. Right before serving, give them a quick dip in hot water to bring them back up to temperature.

📖 Recipe