Pumpkin Gingerbread Loaf Cake

A combination of pumpkin puree, molasses, and gingerbread spices creates a moist and spicy pumpkin gingerbread loaf cake that sings with fall flavors.

This pumpkin gingerbread cake is a riff on King Arthur's Chai Spiced Pound Cake, a rich, moist, lightly spiced bundt cake perfect for winter weather. Since I had some pumpkin puree left over from making my pumpkin spice bagels, I decided to give it an autumn-inspired pumpkin gingerbread twist and bake it up in a loaf pan.

Why a loaf pan? Because more people have loaf pans than have bundt pans and I really wanted you to be able to make this cake!

So hello, fall. Pumpkin Gingerbread Loaf Cake has arrived.

Thank you so much to USA Pan for sponsoring this post. All opinions are my own. And thank YOU so much for supporting the businesses who support The Practical Kitchen!

This pumpkin gingerbread loaf cake would be right at home following a turkey and stuffing dinner complete with pretzel stuffing. Basically, if you're serving a fall-flavored dinner, this fall-flavored dessert is the perfect way to end the meal.

Jump to:

• 👩🏻‍🍳 Why this recipe works
• 📋 Ingredients
• 🔪 Mise en place (aka prep work)
• 🍽 Equipment
• ⏲️ Instructions
• ⭐ BONUS - Cream Cheese Icing
• 📖 Variations
• 📖 Recipe notes & tips
• 💬 Recipe FAQ
• 📖 Recipe
• 💬 Comments

👩🏻‍🍳 Why this recipe works

UPDATE 9/29/21 — I've given this recipe a makeover with all new photos, a more intense gingerbread flavor, and a streamlined, easier to follow recipe. Plus, lots more tips and troubleshooting advice to help you succeed.

With plenty of molasses and ground ginger this pumpkin pound cake definitely leans more heavily on the gingerbread flavor than on the pumpkin spice side of things.

The molasses adds that classic, spicy gingerbread vibe which is emphasized by the blend of warm spices and the addition of chopped ginger snap cookies stirred in at the end. The ginger snap cookies soften in the oven and blend right into the cake texture — adding deliciously warm intensely gingery bites throughout the cake.

While pumpkin puree is usually considered a "fat" for baking purposes, it doesn't cream nicely with the butter and sugar, so instead it gets stirred into the batter at the end along with the molasses and greek yogurt.

This keeps the pumpkin gingerbread loaf cake moist and tender, without compromising its rising power.

📋 Ingredients

Here's what you'll need to make this pumpkin gingerbread loaf cake.

• All purpose flour - I used King Arthur's all purpose, but just use what you've got.
• Butter - Unsalted butter preferred, but salted will work just fine.
• Pumpkin puree - I used store brand generic, there's no need to get fancy here. Just make sure it's 100% pumpkin puree, no sugar added, etc.
• Brown sugar - I use dark brown sugar for extra molasses vibes, but light brown will work too.
• Molasses - I used Grandma's Original brand molasses but if you want extra strong gingerbread vibes, you can use a "robust" molasses instead.
• Large eggs - Self explanatory.
• Greek yogurt - Whole milk, whole fat greek yogurt. This is the secret ingredient that keeps this cake so dang moist! One of those single serve yogurt cups usually has exactly the right amount (or something close to it).
• Baking powder - Don't skip this! It helps the cake rise.
• Baking soda - Gives the cake a little extra boost rising in the oven. If you don't have it, the cake will be a little less tall but okay without it.
• Gingerbread spices - Ground cinnamon (I like Vietnamese cinnamon for its stronger flavor), ground ginger, allspice, ground cloves, and nutmeg (whole nutmeg, freshly grated with a microplane). You can also use a store bought gingerbread spice blend.
• Ginger snap cookies - I used Stauffer's Original Ginger Snap Cookies which I picked up at Stop and Shop. They're crispy and hard, not chewy at all. When chopped up and stirred into the batter they blend right into the cake as it bakes, dotting it with bites of deliciously spicy gingerbread flavor throughout.
• Cinnamon sugar - Optional, to sprinkle on top of the cake before baking.

And here's what you'll need to make the cream cheese icing.

• Cream cheese - Whole fat, softened. If you use low fat or lite cream cheese the consistency will be off, and sometimes it ends up with a strange yellow color instead of white. Remove from the fridge an hour or two before making the icing.
• Butter - Salted or unsalted, either will work. You need it softened, but not melty. Take it out of the fridge an hour or two before you plan to make the icing.
• Powdered sugar - Sift it first to remove any lumps.
• Milk - Whole milk preferred. Heavy cream will also work.

See recipe below for ingredient quantities.

🔪 Mise en place (aka prep work)

Mise en place is a French culinary term which literally translates to "putting in place." It means measuring your ingredients and making sure you have the right tools ready to go before you start working.

This can make a huge difference in a) how enjoyable you find the baking and cooking process and b) the success of your recipe!

For this pumpkin gingerbread loaf cake, there are a lot of small spice quantities to measure, and you'll find it frustrating if you need to stop and dig through your cabinets once the mixer starts running.

Here's the mise en place you'll need for this recipe:

• Soften the butter - Take it out of the fridge the night before or at least 3-4 hours before you plan to bake. You want it soft but not melty. If you need to soften it quickly, I find 4 seconds per side in a microwave does the trick.
• Bring the eggs to room temperature - Leave them out for 20-30 minutes, or submerge in hot water for 3-5 minutes.
• Mix the wet ingredients - Bring the pumpkin puree and greek yogurt to room temperature and mix them together with the molasses. Room temperature ingredients combine much better and contribute to a higher rise in your cake.
• Mix the dry ingredients - Mix all of the dry ingredients except for the brown sugar together in a bowl.
• Chop the gingersnap cookies - This is my recipe and even I kept forgetting this step until the last minute by mistake while I was testing it. So please, please, please, chop the cookies and have them ready to go before you start mixing all the ingredients together. You'll be glad you did.

Tip: Room temperature ingredients incorporate more easily and rise better than cold ingredients. Take the time to get your ingredients to room temperature before mixing for best results.

🍽 Equipment

• 9x5" loaf pan - I baked this in my fave USA Pan 9x5" loaf pan. Not only is USA Pan based in my hometown of Pittsburgh, PA (shoutout to supporting local biz!) they make some of the best cake and baking pans around. What I like most about USA Pan's loaf pans in particular are the sharp 90 degree corners which give your loaf cakes and pound cakes a crisp, polished look. The rippled surface design helps with air flow so the cake bakes evenly and the non-stick surface is super easy to clean. (Thanks again to USA Pan for sponsoring this post, and thank you for supporting the businesses that support The Practical Kitchen!)
• Parchment paper - Even though you'll grease the pan, and even though the pan is non-stick, you'll still want to make a parchment paper sling to make lifting the cake out of the pan as easy as possible. I've been using Kana Goods' 8" square cake parchment liners, but their quarter parchment sheets also work well here.
• Mixer - A stand mixer with a paddle attachment is ideal for the cake batter, though a hand mixer will also work. You can use your stand mixer and paddle for the icing too, but I found it was easier to use a hand mixer for that step. It's really up to you and what you have in your kitchen.

⏲️ Instructions

We're following standard butter cake procedure here: Cream butter and sugar, add the eggs, then alternate adding dry and wet ingredients, ending on the dry and stirring in the chopped cookies to finish.

Start by beating the room temperature butter and brown sugar together with a mixer. It will take about 3-4 minutes at medium-high speed to do this right. Pause and scrape down the bowl every minute or so to make sure everything is mixing together well.

Add the room temperature eggs one at a time, giving each one a full 60 seconds at medium-high speed to incorporate. Scrape down the bowl and paddle before and after adding each egg.

Then, reduce the speed to the lowest possible setting and alternate adding the wet and dry ingredients. Add one-third of the flour and spice mixture, scrape down the bowl, then add half the greek yogurt/pumpkin/molasses mixture and scrape down the bowl.

Repeat until all the wet and dry ingredients have been added. So it goes: Dry-wet-dry-wet-dry.

TIP: Low speed is crucial once you begin adding the flour. Flour + liquid + movement = gluten development, which you don't want here! Gluten provides structure in bread, but it makes cakes tough and dense. Use the lowest possible setting on your mixer, and stop the mixer as soon as each addition of flour or liquid is mostly incorporated.

When there are still a few streaks of flour in the bowl, pause the mixer, scrape the paddle clean, and use a spatula to stir in the chopped cookie pieces. The flour will finish incorporating as you stir in the cookies and reduce the chances of over mixing the batter.

Pour the batter into a greased, parchment-lined 9x5" loaf pan and use a small offset spatula to press it into all the corners and even off the top of the cake. Top with cinnamon sugar (optional) and bake for 55-60 minutes at 350F.

The best way to know that the cake is done is when a toothpick inserted into the middle comes out clean. (Stick the knife into one of the open cracks to hide the entry point.) The cake might still look a little jiggly or under baked at that point, but don't overthink it. If the knife comes out clean, it's done.

Let it cool in the pan for 10-15 minutes, then run a knife around the edges of the pan and gently release it to finish cooling on a rack.

Don't slice it until it's completely cool. The cake will compress slightly as it cools, and if you slice it too soon it'll fall apart instead of cutting cleanly.

⭐ BONUS - Cream Cheese Icing

To make the cream cheese icing, use a hand mixer or the paddle attachment on your stand mixer to cream the softened butter and cream cheese together.

Add the sifted powdered sugar and beat well with the mixer. Start on low speed, then increase gradually so the powdered sugar doesn't go flying everywhere.

At first it will be crumbly and lumpy but just keep mixing and it will turn into a smooth paste. Add the milk 1 teaspoon at a time, beating well between each addition until you reach a pourable but not runny consistency.

I found that 1 tablespoons (3 teaspoons) was the right amount of milk, but you can adjust until it's just how you like it. If it's too runny, add more powdered sugar. If it's too stiff, add another teaspoon of milk.

If you want more of a cream cheese frosting situation, hold back on the milk. If you prefer an icing/glaze, you'll probably want the full amount of milk.

📖 Variations

• Spicy Gingerbread - Double the amount of cloves and ginger snap cookies and use a "robust" molasses.
• Emphasis on the Pumpkin - Replace half the molasses with honey and use just 1 tablespoon ground ginger.
• Chock Full o' Nuts - Stir ½ cup chopped walnuts or pecans into the batter with the cookie pieces. Top the cake with more chopped nuts before baking. If you're using the cream cheese icing, toast the nuts separately and sprinkle them on top after icing.
• Candied Ginger - Instead of chopped ginger snap cookies, you can use crystallized candied ginger bits. They have a similar effect in the cake, but are slightly sweeter, and are a bit harder to find. You'll likely have to order them online.

📖 Recipe notes & tips

• Pay attention to the times included in the recipe — you want to give the butter and sugar plenty of time to cream together, and you want to give the eggs plenty of time to fully incorporate before you add the dry and wet ingredients.
• Scrape down the bowl and paddle after each time you add something to make sure everything mixes together evenly. This step is more important than you think! Don't skip it!
• Wait until the cake is completely cool before you add the cream cheese icing. If you add it while the cake is still warm, it will melt and slide off.
• DO NOT OVER MIX - The reason you add the chopped gingersnap cookies before the flour has completely incorporated is to prevent over mixing. You don't want the flour to start developing gluten (which will make your cake tough), so it's better to let the flour finish mixing in while you stir in the cookies.
• To make the cake as easy to remove from the pan as possible, grease the pan, then insert the parchment liner, then grease the liner. I use a non-stick spray rather than butter, but you can also rub the inside of the pan with the paper from the stick of butter if you're feeling economical.
• If you don't feel like making the cream cheese icing, I recommend dusting lightly with powdered sugar once the cake has cooled.
• The "total time" on the recipe card does not include giving the cake time to cool before icing.

💬 Recipe FAQ

What are you waiting for? Get baking!

📖 Recipe

This post was originally published on 11/1/2019. If you're looking for the original version of this recipe, shoot me an email rebecca@thepracticalkitchen.com!